top of page
Fielder Jones 1914 LoC_edited.jpg

New Stories from the Earlier Innings of America's National Pastime

OTRFW Kindle Cover Final.jpg
Readers Favorite 5 Star Sticker Hi Res.png


Readers' Favorite 5-Star Review

"a wonderfully interesting and romantic story"

--Karen Walpole for Readers' Favorite

"a delightful tale of a bygone era, the late 19th century age of the infancy of organized baseball"

--Bill Meade, Former Sports Editor for Page News and Courier (Luray, Va.)

Player-manager Rory Fitzgerald’s 1891 Richmond Elite Professional Baseball Club enjoys an abundance of talent but isn’t the most disciplined team in the league. When U.S. president Benjamin Harrison makes a surprise appearance at a game between Fitzgerald’s club and the pesky Baltimore Schooners, the Elite let bad habits take hold and soon find themselves on the wrong end of a developing rout. Hoping to avert embarrassment in front of the president and his guests, the young manager inserts himself into the lineup.

Fitzgerald indeed gets a hit, a fly ball that easily outdistances anything he has ever batted before. But the dream hit quickly becomes a nightmare. Fickle as ever, fate carries the ball over the right-field wall only to drop it—of all places—squarely on the rump of the snoozing horse hitched to the president’s waiting carriage. And the carriage isn’t empty. Having retired from the grandstand early, the president’s daughter and her companion are sitting in the open coach, while their driver stands on the sidewalk nearby. The startled horse bolts, and everything goes downhill from there.

Before Fitzgerald knows it, his unlikely hit lands him in the middle of a high-stakes contest for public opinion. Stoked by the press, unexpectedly fueled by politics, and heatedly debated by “polite” society, nothing less than the future of professional baseball hangs in the balance.

So, when Fitzgerald’s solution to the conundrum gets him booted from the sport he loves, will anyone in high places go to bat for him?

2016 Peacemaker Award Winner.png


2020 Readers' Favorite International Book Awards Finalist

"GP Hutchinson took the history of early baseball and created a winning fictional story." --Trudi LoPrieto for Readers' Favorite

2021 SABR Larry Ritter Award Nominee

2021 Firebird Book Awards Winner

"Crime fans and baseball fanatics alike will be enthralled by this retro tale of love and revenge." --BookLife Reviews

"a historically based murder mystery with plenty of surprises--and with a beautiful romantic subplot."

--Gary Livacari, Author of Reflections on the 1919 Black Sox

The year is 1912--the height of what will come to be known as the Deadball Era. Trick pitches and scuffed-up, spit-stained baseballs are not uncommon. The game is played base to base, and aggressive base running is the order of the day. Lots of sliding . . . all too often, cleats high.

In a meaningless late-season game between two bottom-of-the-pack National League teams, talented rookie pitcher Hal Gerecke throws a fastball he will regret as long as he lives. Rube Wannamaker, the popular plate-crowding batter Hal is facing, apparently never catches sight of the incoming pitch and winds up on the ground, unresponsive and bleeding profusely. When Hal refuses to finish the game, his budding Big League career comes to an abrupt end.

News of the debilitating outcome of Hal's pitch breaks quickly, and Rube's more vindictive teammates and fans immediately make Hal their target. In spite of their violent threats, he doesn't flee. Soon, however, concern for the well-being of Rube's young wife prompts him to leave town and return to the menial job he held before making it as a pro.

For a short while, Hal is gone from baseball but by no means forgotten. When a new professional baseball league is established a year later--a league determined to correct some of the more egregious ills of organized baseball--the new league's management eagerly seeks to sign Hal.

With mixed feelings, he agrees to play. Only, as soon as he returns to the diamond, he discovers the lengths to which his unrelenting enemies will go to ruin him or to see him dead.


"Hutchinson again successfully recreates the world of old-time baseball in his third America’s Pastime crime novel (after 2020’s Dead Ball: A Novel of Murder and Passion)…Fans of Robert Goldsborough’s Three Strikes You’re Dead will be pleased." --Publishers Weekly

"Pickoff by GP Hutchinson offers great action, great baseball, a great love story, a great moral dilemma, and crisp direct prose. Hutchinson has hit this one out of the park!"

--Jon Michael Miller for Readers' Favorite

"an incredibly gripping story" --Lesley Jones for Readers' Favorite

A ballplayer. A diva. The mob. Trouble, 1920s style.

Ace major league catcher Joe Rath suddenly finds himself riding the pine when team management decides they've got to have slugger Frank Walsh on the roster. Only, Walsh brings along more baggage than anybody bargains for.

Meanwhile, Rath's troubles multiply. With his wife already discontent back home, he keeps bumping into a certain breathtaking showgirl whose dangerous situation he can't ignore. A Chicago crime boss enters the picture, and things snowball.


Before he knows it, Rath finds himself not only running the basepaths but running for his life. 

Readers Favorite 5 Star Sticker Hi Res.png
bottom of page